Bob has a concession at Yankee Stadium. He can sell 500 umbrellas at $10 each if it rains. (The umbrellas cost him $5 each.) If it shines, he can sell only 100 umbrellas at $10 each and 1000 sunglasses at $5 each. (The sunglasses cost him $2 each.) He has $2500 to invest in one day, but everything that isn’t sold is trampled by the fans and is a total loss. This is a game against nature. Nature has two strategies: rain and shine. Bob also has two strategies: buy for rain or buy for shine. Find the optimal strategy for Bob assuming that the probability for rain is 50%.

Respuesta :

Answer:

The optimal strategy for Bob is buying for shine (unless he can watch a forecast to know the next day weather).

Step-by-step explanation:

This is a typical problem of hopes to win vs hopes to lose. Let's analyze each of the strategies Bob can adopt in both kinds of weather.

Bob buy for rain:

Bob will buy 500 umbrellas for a cost of $5 each. This is a total cost of $2500.

If it rain, Bob can sell all umbrellas for $10 each. This gives a maximum revenue of $5000. Therefore the maximum profit is $2500. Remember that:

Profit= Revenue - Cost

If it's a sunny day, Bob can only sell 100 umbrellas for $10 each. This gives a maximum revenue of $1000. Therefore the maximum profit is -$1500. That means that in this case, the minimum loss is $1500.

Bob buy for Shine:

Bob will buy 100 umbrellas for a cost of $5 each and 1000 sunglasses for a cost of $2 each. This is a total cost of $2500.

If it's a sunny day, Bob can only sell all umbrellas for $10 each and all sunglasses for $5. This gives a maximum revenue of $6000. Therefore the maximum profit is $3500.

If it rains, Bob can sell only sell all the 100 umbrellas for $10 each but none of the sunglasses. Therefore the maximum profit is $1000. Therefore the maximum profit is -$1500. That means that in this case, the minimum loss is $1500.

In both cases, the worst-case scenario is the same: a loss of $1500.

Nevertheless in the best case scenario buying to shine gives a bigger profit. Therefore if the risk is the same, is better to go for the strategy with better profits.