Your uncle Brian stole three t-shirts from a stand at the mall. You are upset that he made this choice, and decide to use your iPhone to secretly record a conversation with him where he admits that he did, in fact, steal the shirts. He is awaiting trial, and you bring the recording to the police station to submit it as evidence. In your state, it is illegal to use a secretly recorded conversation in a court of law. In other words, this piece of evidence is inadmissible. Do you agree with this rule? In your answer, define the exclusionary rule and doctrine of fruit of the poisonous tree, and explain how these terms apply to your situation.

Question

02-12-2020
Law

contestada

Your uncle Brian stole three t-shirts from a stand at the mall. You are upset that he made this choice, and decide to use your iPhone to secretly record a conversation with him where he admits that he did, in fact, steal the shirts. He is awaiting trial, and you bring the recording to the police station to submit it as evidence. In your state, it is illegal to use a secretly recorded conversation in a court of law. In other words, this piece of evidence is inadmissible. Do you agree with this rule? In your answer, define the exclusionary rule and doctrine of fruit of the poisonous tree, and explain how these terms apply to your situation.

Respuesta :

Otras preguntas

The population of a certain species of fish has a relative growth rate of 1.1% per year. It is estimated that the population in 2010 was 12 million. a. Find an

In a sequence, the 40th term is 70, the 41st term is 72 and the 42nd term is 74.a) State the term-to-term ruleb) Work out the first termc) Work out the 80th te

Match each scientist to the observation she is most likely to make.meteorologist?The average dailytemperature of the oceanat the North Pole hasIncreased during

Setting priorities: Fill in the chart below with at least three tasks in each column. First, set the priority of the task by assigning the highest priority task

Yo tenía $5 Mi mamá me dió $10 Mi papá me dió $30 Mi tío y mi tía me dieron $100 Yo tenía otros $20 ¿Cuánto tenía?

The Tang military A. built its strength by developing an idea of ethnic militarism whereby only ethnic Chinese could participate in military service. B. relied

A 95% confidence interval for the mean number of television per American household is (1.15, 4.20). For each of the following statements about the above confide

Help please!!! Thxxxxx

The marked price of a watch is 30% above the cost price. When it is sold allowing20% discount on it, there is a gain of Rs 150. Find the marked price of watch.

are teaching a class on computer hardware to new IT technicians. You are discussing the component on an Advanced Technology eXtended (ATX) motherboard that supp

Sheriff100 Sheriff100 · Answer 1 · 2020-12-02T22:54:27+01:00

Answer: I think that the rule is very wrong and it is very foolish.

I think that if someone is breaking the law, we should be able to provide all the evidence we need to put this thief behind bars.

If nobody recorded, how else would the evidence get to the police?

If nobody recorded, the thief can say that he did not steal anything.

The Police and the Supreme Court need to have evidence that way there is no confusion and that way there is not anymore trouble.

Explanation:

avaclairebrook avaclairebrook · Answer 2 · 2021-02-18T17:54:20+01:00

Answer: I agree with this rule that secretly recorded conversations cannot be used as evidence in a court of law. I agree with this rule because with technology now days it would be all too easy to takes someones words out of contact or even rearrange what was said. This also violates our rights as Americans and takes away our privacy. The fruit of the poisonous tree rule is an extension of the exclusionary rule meaning, illegally gathered evidence cannot be admissible in a court of law, the fruit being the evidence and the poisonous tree being the means in which the evidence was gathered.

Explanation: